The discussion revolves around a curated list of influential books in the realm of science from the past century. However, there is significant skepticism regarding the selections. Critics highlight that several notable books do not feature on the list, pointing out the subjective nature of influence and importance in the vast scientific landscape. Specific mentions include *Dune* for its ecological insights and the absence of significant computing literature. Challenges such as broken links in the resource, and the need for more comprehensive representation of various scientific disciplines, particularly computing and early artificial intelligence, are also raised. The discourse suggests that the evaluation of what constitutes a shaping book often evolves with time and perspective.