The recent discovery involving 'dark oxygen' in the deep sea has ignited a division among scientists regarding its implications. Some argue it poses a threat to marine ecosystems, while others are more skeptical about the findings. Concerns were raised regarding the motivations behind studies that may conflict with the interests of deep-sea mining companies and the potential environmental impacts of mining practices. Furthermore, there are questions regarding the credibility of scientific journals amidst political biases. This highlights the need for independent and transparent research in understanding deep-sea environments and the consequences of human activities, such as mining.