The Polymarket betting market concerning the return of Jesus has stirred a complex discussion about the motivations behind participation and the implications of such bets. Many commenters express skepticism about the likelihood of Jesus' return this year, questioning the seriousness of bets placed and suggesting that participants may not genuinely believe in the outcome, but are drawn to the market's engagement potential. The market reflects not just religious sentiment but intertwines with political beliefs—particularly dispensationalism in U.S. Protestant theology which emphasizes a bleak view of the world and societal decay. The trustworthiness of market resolution sources and the arbitrary nature of betting on metaphysical outcomes further complicate these discussions. As prediction markets continue to evolve, insights into the mechanisms driving market behavior raise questions about the effectiveness of crowdsourced intelligence compared to AI-driven predictions, highlighting a potential shift in how forecasting could be approached within this space.