In a recent discussion, Nick Cave expressed skepticism about AI-generated poetry, asserting that true creativity is rooted in human suffering and experience. This perspective invites a deeper debate on the nature of creativity, suggesting that the emotional struggles associated with artistic creation are essential, while AI lacks genuine feeling and experience. User comments reflect a variety of opinions on the necessity of suffering in art, with some arguing that creativity can emerge from various contexts, not solely from pain. Others highlighted the distinction between real human experiences and virtual ones, asserting that authentic art cannot simply be imitated without the lived experiences of life. The conversation opens up further exploration into how technology and AI intersect with traditional concepts of artistry and creativity.