The article discusses a network science approach used to predict the selection of a new Pope, exploring the dynamics of cardinals and their connections within the conclave. It highlights the methodology, including the algorithms applied, and how the predictions were influenced by the social and political relationships among the cardinals. Some commentators draw parallels to other predictive models, such as those used in political elections, suggesting skepticism regarding the accuracy of such models without a solid track record. There is also a concern over the timing of the publication in relation to the actual papal selection.