The Illuminated Gospel of St John is celebrated for its poetic nature and artistic presentations. Users have expressed admiration for the beauty and precision of the illuminations, noting the need for accurate annotations to understand the deeper cultural and historical allusions within. There is a contrast drawn between the precision of medieval illuminations and the modern decline in handwriting skills, highlighting a renewed appreciation for artisanal craftsmanship. The commentary also references other artistic interpretations of biblical texts, such as Robert Crumb's graphic adaptation of Genesis, showcasing the intersection of traditional and contemporary interpretations of scripture.