The discussion revolves around the perceived negativity in contemporary book reviews for 2024, particularly highlighting the lack of interesting perspectives and the political tone that dominates many of them. Some comments express frustration with the overall tone of these critiques, arguing they're not engaging or insightful. There's a mention of author Sally Rooney being a frequent target in these reviews, suggesting a pattern of critique rather than thoughtful analysis. Overall, while some positive insights can be found, the consensus is that many reviews come off as unoriginal and overly critical without adding substantial value for readers. This sentiment raises questions about the impact of reviewers' biases and trends on reader engagement and discourse around literature. There's also a call for more constructive criticism that focuses on enhancing literary discussions rather than simply tearing down works.