The discussion around 'Clean Code' and 'A Philosophy of Software Design' centers on differing approaches to software development practices. Many user comments express skepticism about Martin's (Uncle Bob's) rigid adherence to clean code principles, arguing that they can lead to impractical coding practices, such as aesthetic uniformity at the cost of productivity. Critics highlight the importance of adaptability in coding styles based on project needs and the team's dynamics. The need for comments in code for clarity, especially in complex scenarios, is also emphasized, suggesting that some principles may not fit all situations. The discussion points to a broader debate about dogma versus pragmatism in software development practices, with recommendations for alternative readings that offer more practical guidance on software design.