Overengineered anchor links and active indicators in web design can complicate user experience. Users question the purpose of the active anchor indicators, suggesting that they might not be beneficial for small sections of text. The conversation highlights different design perspectives, including opinions favoring simpler solutions like adding padding to improve visibility. Users appreciate the refreshing design of the original article and express specific preferences regarding usability on mobile versus desktop. Many conversations revolve around the effectiveness of JavaScript-based interactions versus traditional HTML elements, raising the critical point of functionality for users without JavaScript. Overall, while the design has its merits, there is significant feedback pushing towards clearer, simpler solutions for navigation and accessibility.